Why do people port over existing paradigms to new tech
I've observed this pattern repeatedly throughout my career - when new technologies emerge, people almost always start by porting existing paradigms rather than exploring what's truly new and possible.
When the web came around, everybody was trying to port desktop apps to the web. And then when mobile came around, everybody's trying to port websites to mobile. And this pattern just repeats over and over again.
This happens because we've had way less time to figure things out. And again, very likely that what we're doing is applying the lessons or the learnings we have from one platform to a new platform. But that may not necessarily be the right thing to do.
Looking at history, this isn't unique to digital technology. If you look at the transition from, say, a radio over to TV, there were business models, there were formats, and there were things that worked in radio that when TV came around, everybody just tried to move it over to TV. The first TV programs were literally radio shows with a poster - it took time to discover what TV was actually good at.
Similarly, we've been using print metaphors for the web for years. We call things pages. We use grid layouts.
As Scott Jenson put it, the process is "copy, extend, and finally, discovery of a new form. It takes a while to shed old paradigms."
In the early stages, when these platform potentials come out, there's this tendency to just repeat and rehash and try and port. And you don't really get to see the true potential of stuff unless you dig into it, start playing with it, try to build things, try to design things.