Reminds me of how “PM and legal” design products vs how a designer designs products


Yes, there's a common thread. In both cases things end up on the screen because someone (or something) had a reason to add them, and nobody owned the job of taking them away.

When I ask teams why their product has 15 screens of legal copy, a pile of permission dialogs, and an intro tour, I usually hear "legal made me do it." That might sound like a valid reason, but it opens a gap between what something is and why it exists. Instead of reflecting why the product exists, the form starts to reflect the organizational structure, with requirements coming from siloed parts of the company that each see the world differently. The experience ends up being whatever legal or PM told us to do, and we start doing things for reasons other than our customers.

The other common justification is "everybody's doing it." Teams run a competitive analysis, see that Jump, Spin, Bird, and Lime all have intro tours, and conclude intro tours are probably a good idea because everybody else has one. That's pretty close to how an AI model designs too: it adds what it has seen most often.

So what does a designer do differently? Test whether each piece earns its spot. Vevo noticed people were skipping through their tutorial without reading it, so they removed it. In a 28-day experiment with over 160,000 participants, more people got into the app, more completed sign-up, and engagement and retention didn't change.

To be fair to PMs and lawyers (some of my best friends, etc.), the fix is a shared process, and pointing fingers won't get you there. Don Norman's old diagram makes the point well: when technology, marketing, and user experience act as separate legs, the product wobbles. When they're connected, it holds together.

Back in 2019 I joked that many UX teams should be renamed "UX was ruined by PM, Business, etc. I just do design" teams. That's the outcome to avoid. Whenever something is on screen, ask who it's for. If the answer is a department (or a model's habits) instead of a customer, it's a good candidate for removal.